| Last Name | First Name | Team | Position | Price |
| Mauer | Joe | MIN | C | 22 |
| McCann | Brian | ATL | C | 21 |
| Martin | Russell | LA | C | 19 |
| Soto | Geovany | CHC | C | 16 |
| Molina | Bengie | SF | C | 15 |
| Martinez | Victor | CLE | C | 15 |
| Doumit | Ryan | PIT | C | 13 |
| Suzuki | Kurt | OAK | C | 12 |
| Pierzynski | A.J. | CHW | C | 12 |
| Iannetta | Chris | COL | C | 10 |
| Hernandez | Ramon | CIN | C | 10 |
| Navarro | Dioner | TB | C | 10 |
| Molina | Yadier | STL | C | 10 |
| Kendall | Jason | MIL | C | 10 |
| Posada | Jorge | NYY | C | 10 |
| Johjima | Kenji | SEA | C | 9 |
| Wieters | Matt | BAL | C | 8 |
| Napoli | Mike | ANA | C | 8 |
| Snyder | Chris | ARI | C | 8 |
| Barajas | Rod | TOR | C | 7 |
| Ruiz | Carlos | PHI | C | 7 |
| Laird | Gerald | DET | C | 7 |
| Schneider | Brian | NYM | C | 7 |
| Rodriguez | Ivan | NYY | C | 7 |
| Baker | John | FLA | C | 7 |
| Shoppach | Kelly | CLE | C | 6 |
| Clement | Jeff | SEA | C | 6 |
| Flores | Jesus | WAS | C | 6 |
| Varitek | Jason | BOS | C | 6 |
| Buck | John | KC | C | 5 |
| Saltalamacchia | Jarrod | TEX | C | 5 |
| Zaun | Gregg | BAL | C | 5 |
| Olivo | Miguel | KC | C | 5 |
| Coste | Chris | PHI | C | 4 |
| Hundley | Nick | SD | C | 4 |
| Bard | Josh | BOS | C | 4 |
| Towles | J.R. | HOU | C | 4 |
| Montero | Miguel | ARI | C | 4 |
| Torrealba | Yorvit | COL | C | 3 |
| Barrett | Michael | TOR | C | 3 |
| Mathis | Jeff | ANA | C | 3 |
| Paulino | Ronny | PHI | C | 3 |
| Teagarden | Taylor | TEX | C | 3 |
| Riggans | Shawn | TB | C | 3 |
| Castro | Ramon A. | NYM | C | 2 |
| LoDuca | Paul | FLA | C | 2 |
| Ramirez | Max | TEX | C | 2 |
| Redmond | Mike | MIN | C | 2 |
| Salome | Angel | MIL | C | 2 |
| Estrada | Johnny | WAS | C | 2 |
| Valentin | Javier | CIN | C | 2 |
| Ross | David | ATL | C | 2 |
| LaRue | Jason | STL | C | 2 |
| Molina | Jose | NYY | C | 2 |
| Palmisano | Lou | HOU | C | 1 |
| Hanigan | Ryan | CIN | C | 1 |
| May | Lucas | LA | C | 1 |
| Nieves | Wil | WAS | C | 1 |
| Ryan | Dusty | DET | C | 1 |
| Ausmus | Brad | LA | C | 1 |
| Arencibia | J.P. | TOR | C | 1 |
| Conger | Hank | ANA | C | 1 |
| Bako | Paul | CHC | C | 1 |
| Treanor | Matt | DET | C | 1 |
| Thigpen | Curtis | TOR | C | 1 |
| Quintero | Humberto | HOU | C | 1 |
| Powell | Landon | OAK | C | 1 |
| Johnson | Rob | SEA | C | 1 |
| Kottaras | George | BOS | C | 1 |
| Rabelo | Mike | FLA | C | 1 |
| Montz | Luke | WAS | C | 1 |
| Hall | Toby | HOU | C | 1 |
| Holm | Steve | SF | C | 1 |
| Ellis | A.J. | LA | C | 1 |
| Hill | Koyie | CHC | C | 1 |
| Rivera | Mike | MIL | C | 1 |
| Quiroz | Guillermo | BAL | C | 1 |
| Blanco | Henry | SD | C | 1 |
| Johnson | Mark | CHC | C | 1 |
| Burke | Jamie | SEA | C | 1 |
| Budde | Ryan | ANA | C | 1 |
| Ojeda | Miguel | TEX | C | 1 |
| Alfonzo | Eliezer | SD | C | 1 |
| Melhuse | Adam | TEX | C | 1 |
| Bowen | Rob | OAK | C | 1 |
| Moeller | Chad | BAL | C | 1 |
| Laforest | Pete | PHI | C | 1 |
| Armstrong | Cole | CHW | C | 1 |
| Lucy | Donny | CHW | C | 1 |
| Marson | Lou | PHI | C | 1 |
| Wilson | Bobby | ANA | C | 1 |
| Molina | Gustavo | WAS | C | 1 |
| Anderson | Bryan | STL | C | 1 |
| Bellorin | Edwin | COL | C | 1 |
| Wilson | Vance | DET | C | 1 |
| Bennett | Gary | LA | C | 1 |
| Miller | Corky | CHW | C | 1 |
| Morton | Colt | SD | C | 1 |
| Ardoin | Danny | LA | C | 1 |
| Santana | Carlos | CLE | C | 1 |
| Santos | Omir | NYM | C | 1 |
| Sardinha | Dane | DET | C | 1 |
| Skelton | James | ARI | C | 1 |
| DiFelice | Mike | TB | C | 1 |
| Diaz | Robinzon | PIT | C | 1 |
| Hammock | Robby | BAL | C | 1 |
| Flowers | Tyler | CHW | C | 1 |
| Rodriguez | Guillermo | BAL | C | 1 |
| Sammons | Clint | ATL | C | 1 |
| Rivera | Rene | NYM | C | 1 |
| Fasano | Sal | CLE | C | 1 |
| Heintz | Chris | BAL | C | 1 |
| Cash | Kevin | NYY | C | 1 |
| Casanova | Raul | NYM | C | 1 |
| Cervelli | Francisco | NYY | C | 1 |
| Carlin | Luke | SD | C | 1 |
| Cancel | Robinson | NYM | C | 1 |
| Pena | Brayan | KC | C | 1 |
| Paul | Josh | TB | C | 1 |
| Jaramillo | Jason | PIT | C | 1 |
| Tupman | Matt | KC | C | 1 |
| Jaso | John | TB | C | 1 |
| Stewart | Chris | CHW | C | 1 |
| Hernandez | Michel | TB | C | 1 |
| Phillips | Paul | COL | C | 1 |
| Hoover | Paul | PHI | C | 1 |
| Chavez | Raul | TOR | C | 1 |
| House | J.R. | KC | C | 1 |